Keith Butterfield, Yacht and Marine Surveyor. Costa del Sol, Spain.
Free Surface Effect (FSE)—a phenomenon that has contributes to capsizing incidents, and stability emergencies. A partially filled tank – fuel, ballast water, lubricating oil, or any liquids – when a vessel rolls or pitches, the liquid inside moves freely from side to side. This movement creates a shifting center of gravity; it raises the tanks centre of gravity. The danger lies in the reduction of the ship’s metacentric height (GM), which is a key measure of stability.
As the free surface moment increases the effective GM decreases. Lower GM means reduced righting ability and greater vulnerability to excessive rolling. The situation becomes more dangerous in wide tanks. Since free surface moment is strongly influenced by tank breadth, a wide, shallow tank can have a far greater impact on stability than a narrow one containing the same volume of liquid.
Every partially filled tank introduces a stability penalty. Many vessels are lost not because they lacked buoyancy—but because they lost stability.
A tank that either completely full or completely empty is safer than one partially filled. In ship stability, danger is measured by how much freedom onboard water has to move.