Keith Butterfield, Yacht and Marine Surveyor. Costa del Sol, Spain.
Toilet-discharge hose generally labeled ‘sanitation hose’ is an impermeable (including smell) type. It is available in PVC and Rubber; the choice depends on a few factors:
PVC sanitation hose is specially compounded from a high-density material with greater than normal wall thickness to increase resistance to moisture absorption. As a result, it is stiff and difficult to fit tightly to any hose barbs. If the barb is undersized the clamping pressure will cut into the hose and cause it to develop cracks (creating hard-to-trace leaks) at the edge of the clamp. If the barb is too big and the hose has to be stretched, the hose will work-harden and again develop cracks where it has been stretched.
Rubber sanitation hose is more tolerant than PVC to poor barb fitting. It also has greater flexibility and its heavy-wall construction resists permeation much longer.
When installing sanitation hoses, either PVC or rubber, avoid creating low spots that will retain waste and support the hose more frequently over long runs and siphon breaks.