Keith Butterfield, Yacht and Marine Surveyor. Costa del Sol, Spain.

A larger diameter produces more thrust and, in most cases, more efficiency. The benefits are that it gets the boat on plane more easily and quickly by overcoming the resistance from the boat and loads. It keeps the boat on plane at a lower rpm, important in rough seas. The added surface area of larger diameter overcomes the additional resistance from the big waves and strong wind. It takes advantage of the engine’s torque and gives more control in bad weather.

A large diameter has less slippage at low and medium rpm giving higher cruising speed and lower fuel consumption. It also gives better thrust for slow-speed response when manoeuvering in tight spaces.

The down sides are: Increased loads on engine and gearbox – the lower unit’s gearbox is bigger to accommodate the larger gears required to support the torque generated by the large-diameter, this further increases drag; reduced top speed — it has less efficiency because more surface area is wet and causes more drag.

If the goal is to cruise at medium rpm or we usually have our boat loaded, then a large diameter propeller is the best choice. On the other hand, if we are interested in higher speeds, a smaller-diameter propeller is the best choice.

For all-around handling and heavy-weather performance it’s better to use a large diameter propeller and accept the reduced top speed.