Keith Butterfield, Yacht and Marine Surveyor. Costa del Sol, Spain.

It is generally perceived that transversely framed vessels are easier to build. However, a hull with a parallel mid-body it is relatively easy to fabricate a longitudinally framed mid-body section, since the longitudinals have an easy run in areas of equal width. In the bow and stern areas, where the width measurement decreases rapidly, the longitudinals will require more bending to get the form required. Hence it is usual practice to adopt the transverse framing system in the fore and aft regions.

Once the average stresses are derived, each section is assessed for buckling. Calculations are carried out on all critical parts of each section in accordance with the SSC Rules. Several areas will then require an increase in scantlings.

There is one benefit of longitudinal framing which should be borne in mind, and that is the reserve factor over progressive failure. With transversely framed decks the only longitudinally effective material is the deck plate and girders. Should the upper deck exceed its buckling stress only the girders are left to carry the in-plane loads. With longitudinally framed decks the effective longitudinal material also includes the secondary stiffeners. The stiffeners have a buckling capacity far higher than the plating and so should the deck plate exceed its buckling stress the longitudinals and girders will generally be able to carry the in plane load and prevent progressive failure.

A hybrid framing system is often used which combines longitudinally framed decks with a transversely framed sides and double bottom. At vessel lengths much beyond 85m a longitudinally framed double bottom will also be required.  

Practical construction constraints preclude achieving a structure which is close to rule minimum scantlings. Consequently the adoption of a longitudinal framing system can be of limited benefit for large yacht sizes as surface fairness, robustness and noise and vibration requirements penalise the ability to build a very light longitudinally framed structure. A mixed framing system which employs a transversely framed side and bottom structure in conjunction with longitudinally framed decks is a good compromise between weight and practical limitations on these types of vessel.