Keith Butterfield, Yacht and Marine Surveyor. Costa del Sol, Spain.
For larger yachts the considerations of construction and strength differ. The majority of large steel motors yachts are transversely framed – heavy plate spaced at 600 to 800mm pitch. The principal longitudinal stiffening material is the hull and deck plating.
There are advantages and disadvantages to both systems but the fundamental difference from a structural point of view is related to the ability of the stiffened plate to carry in-plane loads. Longitudinal bending of the hull girder, due to buoyancy and weight distribution and the action of the waves, will induce stresses in the fore and aft direction in larger vessels. Thin shell plate is susceptible to buckling, and due to the orientation of the transverse frames hull panels will have roughly a quarter of the strength of a longitudinally framed panel of the same size and thickness. As a result, transversely framed vessels tend to have to have thicker plating, particularly on the decks, in order to have adequate buckling capacity to resist hull to deck beam loads. As the size of a vessel increases the significance of hull to deck beam loads increases dramatically; Lloyd’s generally require strength calculations for all steel hulled yachts over 50m. Currently small vessels are generally transversely framed, and larger vessels, when loads become significant, are generally longitudinally framed. The transition occurs around 50m dependent on vessel type and usage.
A limited number use longitudinal framing systems with transverse frames at 1200mm to 2400mm pitch and closely spaced longitudinal stringers. This combination of framing employs both transverse and longitudinal framing within the same section. Typically this would entail longitudinal framing for most of the decks, with the remainder of the structure being transversely framed. A longitudinally framed structure is more time consuming to construct due to welding of the longitudinals to the shell as well as bracketing or collaring of longitudinals at bulkheads. However this must be offset against the high number of transverse frames found in a transverse system. Weight is often cited as the reason for selecting one system or the other, it is generally accepted that a longitudinally framed structure will be lighter. Most high speed light weight vessels feature longitudinally framed structures.