Keith Butterfield, Yacht and Marine Surveyor. Costa del Sol, Spain.

Poor penetration, lack of penetration and excess penetration is usually a result of not achieving a good quality join. All completed welds should be visually inspected under good lighting. A magnifying glass and straight edge may be used. Undercutting can be detected with the naked eye and (provided there is a reverse side) excess penetration can often be visually detected. Any detected cracks must be ground out and the area re-welded to give the required profile and then the joint must be inspected again.

Through visual examination, with experience, the unaided eye can reveal lack of penetration by the weld metal, badly oxidised or rough surfaces, the presence of large cracks and their position relative to the weld, surface porosity, and inadequate fusion of the weld as shown by ‘undercutting’ and concavity of the weld. Hammer sounding – listening for dull sounds that could indicate weld discontinuitycan be used but will not outline hairline cracks.

However, if the suspected fault is very small, or if access is restricted, then a range of equipment is available to aid the eye: Dye penetrant/penetrant testing (PT) – originally developed as a surface inspection technique for non-magnetic material in lieu of magnetic particle flaw detection. Ultrasound (UT) – ultrasonic detectors can detect cracks and other flaws and are especially helpful in finding hidden flaws in welds. Magnetic Particle Flaw Detection (MPI) – commonly used for weld inspections in ferro-magnetic materials such as carbon steel. It may not be used on paramagnetic (non or weakly magnetic) materials. Radiographic testing (RT) consists of passing penetrating gamma or x-rays through the test piece and an imprint is left on photographic film. Any discontinuities will then be noticeable in the image.