Keith Butterfield, Yacht and Marine Surveyor. Costa del Sol, Spain.

Do old boats pose environmental or safety risks that would justify them being taken out of use? It is justified for some of the oldest rowboats as the safety requirements, especially regarding buoyancy, have become stricter since the Recreational Craft Directive came into force in 1998.

When it comes to the lifespan of larger boats, you have to consider the total costs. Updating the interior, sails, engine, and other technology in a recreational boat can become quite expensive in relation to the boats total value. A boat is primarily a recreational investment, a boat in good condition can be renovated and modernised several times to extend its lifespan. A well-maintained fibreglass boat is almost immortal, and renovating older boats is an important part of the hobby for many.

As a source of micro-plastics in oceans or lakes, old boats are not particularly significant because the material does not degrade significantly. However it is important to ensure that boats taken out of use are recycled properly. A small portion of boats for various reasons, reach the end of their lifespan earlier than usual. To accelerate recycling, one could consider a scrapping bonus for boats and an obligation for local authorities to deliver all composite waste for recycling instead of incineration. However, this system is not suitable for products like boats, whose recycling volume is low and whose lifespan can cover several generations of users. Additionally, the administrative costs would be too high in relation to the benefits.