Keith Butterfield, Yacht and Marine Surveyor. Costa del Sol, Spain.
Invoices should be completely transparent, management companies should only invoice you for their time. If a subcontractor is brought in to work on your boat, you should know who that contractor is and see all their invoices.
Management companies most benefit you in the role of manager, not middleman marking up the subcontractor’s work.
Another way to evaluate the value or cost of a management company is looking at how it charges. Is it by the hour, by the meter/size of the boat? Each method has advantages and disadvantages, so discuss with them what works best for both of you. Another draw of a yacht manager is saving money by avoiding mistakes made during DIY repairs.
Yacht managers bring value by their experience. Problems on a boat come from a variety of causes. Experienced yacht managers have seen more problems on the multiple boats they manage than hopefully you will ever experience. Their expertise saves time and money by zeroing in on the likely cause of a problem right away.
If you have a good relationship with the boat yard where your vessel is lifted and serviced. Hiring a yacht manager does not have to interfere or replace that relationship; in an ideal world it enhances it. A good service yard manager and a good yacht manager do not view each other as competitors, but rather partners in helping you maintain your boat. Yacht managers often have a better relationship with a yard in the same way they do with technicians due to the number of boats a yacht manager can bring to a yard. This has the potential to move you up in the schedule or give you a quicker turnaround in your project.
A yacht manager can meet technicians on your boat during the week when you might otherwise have to take time off work. They can stay on top of technicians working on your boat, because it is their full-time job, while it is a distraction from yours.