Keith Butterfield, Yacht and Marine Surveyor. Costa del Sol, Spain.

TBT tin is the best biocide but is terrible for the environmental – it hasn’t been used for decades.

Today, cuprous oxide is the favoured biocide. Effective, but still tough on the environment. The higher the concentration of copper, the more effective — and the more biocides that leech into the water. More environmentally-friendly biocides – zinc omadine, zinc pyrithione, thiocyanate, and Econea – generally don’t match the protection level of cuprous oxide.

The organic compound medetomidine, which stimulates larval barnacles to keep them swimming rather than attaching to a hull, remains an unproven newcomer and the effect on other forms of growth hasn’t yet been validated.